Wonder Wednesday: Degenerate Art

While expanding their empire in Europe, the Nazi party regularly collected famous works of art from museums and governments, as well as from the Jewish people that they moved and later imprisoned. Much of the art of the time period was influenced by ideas that are now commonplace in art; expressionism, dadaism, abstraction, the Bauhaus movement, anything having to do with jazz. The Nazis affiliated the popularity of these movements with the Jewish art salesmen of the time, equating them to lesser forms and more debase behavior.

Modern art was perceived by many of the Nazi leadership as “degenerate,” or not representative of the ideals of the Aryan race. The regime created a large exhibit to shame and ridicule these works of art, to bring the public in line with their views. It traveled throughout the Nazi territory crammed into tight spaces and overrun with people. In fact it was one of the most scene art exhibits of all time. And after the exhibit was through, the Nazi leadership sought to destroy many of these works and many others that were never displayed.

The Neue Galerie in New York is currently hosting an exhibit to present the subject called “Degenerate Art: The Attack on Modern Art in Nazi Germany, 1937.” Images from the gallery give a sense for what was lost and what it was being replaced with. One room features empty frames for works that were destroyed, along with some images of what they might have been. In another room the large works favored by the Nazi’s are arranged in such a way as to overshadow the degenerate art crowded into the corners. It is a sobering reminder of how culture can be commandeered, altered, and destroyed at the hands of leaders.

It  is a wonder to me this Wednesday that we have the freedom to create and express without anyone threatening to remove our works of art. At the same time, we as Christians can be quick to label or reject art from our culture. Would we, if given the power, label the works of art in our culture in the same way the Nazis did? Does it make you as uncomfortable as me that my answer to that question is “I’m not sure”?

Art is an amazing piece of communication, a representation and an idea at once. As leaders in our spheres of influence, in the realm of art that we encounter, how can we be ambassadors for God and engage with the art? Do we ask the deeper questions about what the art is and why it’s in favor before we judge it? Does that give some insight into why our culture feels about the church the way it does?

Beloved art community, we have a difficult calling; to at once love and act righteously, to call for repentance while we repent, and to make sure that no one walks away from us not knowing the almighty love, grace, and power of God. Have you been critical and negative when you were called to be kind and patient? Let’s all ask for forgiveness and for the perspective of God – to love the creators around us the way our Creator does.

If you are interested, here is a not so great version of a documentary about Degenerate Art from an exhibit at LACMA in 1993:

Advertisements

3 comments

  1. An interesting topic and difficult for me to answer. I have felt that as long as art does not degrade a person or group then art is whatever the artist wants or tries to say. The who decides what is degrading?

    1. I agree that it is a difficult subject. There are lines in our times that people have tried to blur – especially the line between art and eroticism or pornography. Often artists feel like they need to offend their audience in some way to elicit a response. For the Nazis modern art was offensive because they judged it as distorting reality and as a product of a culture steeped in alcohol and sex. Did it degrade a person or group – yes, they would say, it degrades the observer.

      I end up asking the question – God, how do we love these artists and at the same time try to engage with what they are saying? How do I approach art that does offend me, that is distasteful, and act like Jesus? Do I wag my finger, take them off the walls? Do I condone them? Or do I build a bridge, start a friendship, encourage, challenge, and ask for discernment?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s